In this coming together of family and peoplehood, we are again reminded of the stories of the patriarchs, in which the family represents the people. God gave Israel the Torah to enable us to direct those drives. By submitting above, you agree to our privacy policy. They too wanted to enter and reside in the Land of Israel. Please ensure your answer MEETS all our guidelines. Why does the second bowl of popcorn pop better in the microwave? Orpahs arch nemesis was Ruth the one who did hold on, and who turned her commitment to achieve into a lifetime of greatness. As soon as Orpah parted company with Naomi and Ruth, she went to the absolute opposite extreme. Why did Ruth and Orpah make different decisions? Is idle hands are the devil's workshop' biblical statement? 1:8, 1:11 and 1:12; the Talmud derives from her the number of times a potential convert is to be dissuaded). Anonymous (via GotQuestions). Is it pashut pshat that Rut never ate breakfast? The Book of Ruth, too, is about exile and return, land and people. Tamar bears twins, Perez and Zerah, after she masquerades as a prostitute to seduce her father-in-law, Judah, who had failed to fulfill his promise to give her his youngest son Shelah as a husband after his two older sons had died while married to her (Genesis 38). Jesus Christ the executed messiah came through the David line as required by Biblical prophecy. In the book of Ruth, we meet two sisters-in-law, Orpah and Ruth, who chose different paths one toward God, the other returned to familiar people and gods. Your email address will not be published. An easily researchable task through simply following the lineage of David and the inclusion of Ruth in the genealogy of Christ in Matthews Gospel. What's the explanation of this Yalkut (if there is any)? 1 In the days when the judges ruled,[ a] there was a famine in the land. Rachel, initially barren, is jealous of Leahs ability to bear children and so supplies her maidservant Bilhah to Jacob for this purpose (as Sarah had done for Abraham). I overpaid the IRS. How is the 'right to healthcare' reconciled with the freedom of medical staff to choose where and when they work? And there are other parallels which can be pointed out. RuthBig Theme, Little Book by Adele Berlin originally appeared in Bible Review, August 1996. Just like African-Americans are Americans of African descent. (Revelation 21:4). Either way, Orpahs name reveals a sense of running away or turning away. Before that Yaweh was probably part of Ruths ovreall Pantheon of Gods, a Trinity or more of Gods. The child born to Ruth and Boaz is a sonborn to Naomi who will renew her life. For Naomi, Ruth is better than seven sons (Ruth 4:15), for she produces what Naomis sons failed to, an heir. What are the biblical principles for solid decision-making? Share Naomis family lived as foreigners in a hostile land. Orpah, as a mere agent in the story, serves as a foil for Ruth. Ruth was "of the women of Moab" but was genetically linked to Israel through Lot, the nephew of Abraham ( Ruth 1:4; Genesis 11:31; 19:37 ). In different Bibles, the Book of Ruth is put in different places. Did Job believe God would kill him (Job 13:15)? By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. What will be different when the old order of things ends? In the book of Ruth it never openly states that she converts and in fact she is referred to as Ruth the Moabite throughout the text. Are there scriptures to support any model of the shape of the earth? The burden of this inheritance both informed and influenced the choices that these sisters made. So a man from Bethlehem in Judah, together with his wife and two sons, went to live for a while in the country of Moab. The story of Ruth and Naomi is one of the best-loved stories in the Bible. We are to take our strongest feelings and emotions and direct them towards God. Naomi made 2 decisions here; one is to leave Moab and the second is to return. Gods covenant with Abraham lies at its heart. Although she doesnt know it, the field she chooses belongs to a wealthy kinsman of Elimelech named Boaz. Answer: The biblical commentaries discuss the question that you ask, and they suggest different answers. And they wept again. (1) A sojourn in Moab. redeemer. Tamela Turbeville wants every woman to know God loves them, no matter what their past looks like. Raise your eyes and look out from where you are, to the north and south, to the east and west, for I give all the land that you see to you and your offspring forever. Not only that it also opens up the reality that Jesus not only came to redeem the chosen ones but also the gentiles who like Ruth left her old gods and identity for a new identity in Christ, the executed messiah!! A good answer provides new insight and perspective. The Book of Ruth teaches us mans enormous potential for greatness and the catastrophic results if such greatness is misdirected. We will discuss how Providence and human choice interacts to shape the history on individuals and nations, God . Could these translations be too harsh? In the diagram, list what some of the disadvantages of choosing to go with Naomi to Bethlehem might have been. And how to capitalize on that? Where can I find a consolidated list of converts who are mentioned in the Bible, Mishnah and Talmud? Copyright 2023, iBelieve.com. The story opens with Naomis clan having left the land of promise, and their faith, for a new life in the land of Moab, apart from God. They went into the country of Moab and remained there. On the other hand, Orpah passes away into obscurity after she says goodbye to Naomi and Ruth on the road to Bethlehem. It was that belief (which she would have shared in common with Naomi) that . However, the family and people part of the covenant theme is more prominent than the land part in the Book of Ruth. The meaning of ones name identifies a person's character, but the definition of Orpah is not clear. Now it came to pass, in the days when the judges ruled, that there was a famine in the land. He dies in Moab. It is clear (at least from the p'shat of the text)that she didn't go through any formal conversion process that we would recognize today. Ruth vows, Your people will be my people and your God my God, a declaration of love and loyalty cemented when Ruth marries Elimelechs wealthy kinsman, Boaz. Last Week's Top Questions . One path can lead away from God, and the other takes us toward God and into His loving care and protection. Israel and Its Enemies Matt 7:14 For the gate is narrow and the way is hard that leads to life, and those who find it are few. Orpah did not want to leave Naomi and return to Moab, but the desire to be a wife and mother weighed heavily. Boaz declared his hope that doing so would "cause the name of the dead man to rise upon his inheritance.". New external SSD acting up, no eject option. Naomi's two sons married Moabite women called Orpah and Ruth. There are indeed a lot of opinions on when Ruth underwent conversion. Naturally, the Book of Ruth continues with the story of Naomi and Ruth how they return impoverished to Bethlehem, how Ruth attracts the notice of Naomis illustrious relative Boaz, and how she unconventionally hints to him that he marry her and preserve Elimelechs family line. They were Ephrathites from Bethlehem in Judah. Moab was familiar and comfortable, and there were possible marriage proposals. Browse other questions tagged, Like any library, Mi Yodeya offers tons of great information, but, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. She asks her two daughter in-laws to leave her. Although distant relatives, the Moabites and Israelites cultivated a long-standing dislike for each other. Thus, the rabbi disagreed as to when Ruth converted. The Fall of the House of Orpah. should I perhaps add it to the original question? But Ruth makes a different decision, revealing not only her dedication to her mother-in-law, but her dedication to the God of Israel (As Naomi noted, Orpah was . She was from Moab and was the daughter-in-law of Naomi and wife of Chilion. God gave us the Torah to direct our energies towards goodness and meaningful achievement. It is therefore entirely appropriate that Orpah accedes to Naomis suggestion that she remain in Moab with her parental family. Get our Question of the Week delivered right to your inbox! All rights reserved. When he sees the text refer to Ruth as "", he explains that even though she had already converted, she still retained some of the nature of her original upbringing in the way she conducted herself. However, Orpah may deserve more grace than we often give her. 1. Comments are sorted chronologically. @bookofruth Moabite is an demonym not a religion. Ruth, on the contrary, was renouncing the polytheism of the Moabites and embracing the monotheism of the Hebrews. This Ruth does. In Judah she was considered worthless as a widow. So Ruth spoke: "Do not plead with me to abandon you, to turn back from accompanying you; for where you go I shall go, and where you spend the night I shall spend the night. Does a halachically circumcised non-Jew need Hatafat Dam when converting? . Did Job believe God would kill him (Job 13:15)? Dig into the illuminating world of the Bible with a BAS All-Access membership. After Naomi's continued encouragement, Orpah agreed and returned to her family (Ruth 1:14).Naomi then told Ruth, "Look . Ask a Question. The story of Ruth and Naomi is a unique story being the fact that there are only two female books in the bible which the book of Ruth was part of because male is given more preferences then. Shmuel wished to show how even though Ruth was a Moabite, she was a righteous woman and earned the respect and marriage of the great shofet Boaz. your sister-in-law is going back to her people and her gods. She lives in Arkansas and while writing she is surrounded by her six rescue dogs who are usually sleeping. The theme that unites the books from Genesis through Kings and informs much of the Prophets and the Writings is the land and the people. Ruth said, "Don't urge me to leave you or to turn . Naomi stands on the road to Judah as her two Moabite daughters-in-law, Ruth and Orpah, beg to accompany her to her native land in this watercolor by Salvador Dali. What does the Bible say about decision-making. But wherever the story of Ruth appears in your Bible, you will want to find it and study it again after you read RuthBig Theme, Little Book, originally published in the August 1996 issue of Bible Review. By Adele Berlin. How to determine chain length on a Brompton? Thus and more may the Lord do to me if anything but death part me from you. Are we allowed to ask someone if he's a convert? rev2023.4.17.43393. When the story opens, Naomis sons have just died. However, there is a minor figure in the Book of Ruth named Orpah. Why did Ruth stay with Naomi after Orpah decided to return home? Mahlon (Hebrew: Maln) and Chilion ( ilyn) were two brothers mentioned in the Book of Ruth.They were the sons of Elimelech of the tribe of Judah and his wife Naomi.Together with their parents, they settled in the land of Moab during the period of the Israelite Judges.On foreign soil, Mahlon married the Moabite convert Ruth (Ruth 4:10) while Chilion . Why isn't God mentioned more in the book of Ruth? It doesn't change their American-ness. Why did Boaz not want anyone to know Ruth was at the threshing floor? Through marriage, the two women become sisters-in-law and family. PDF | This study aims to conduct a theological study to answer questions, including: why did Boaz want to marry Ruth? Kovetz Haoros Ubeurim Oholei Torah, no. The Book of Ruth begins with a tale of famine in the Holy Land. An Orpah Choice (Ruth 1:8-14) In verse 8, Naomi instructs her two daughters-in-law to "go back, each of you, to your mother"s home.". His wife and sons stay on, and the sons marry non-Jewish women Moabite princesses by the names of Ruth and Orpah. "Your people shall be my people, and your God my God" (Ruth 1:16). Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. While many believe Ruth converted when she said in 1:16, that your G-d is my G-d, Gersonides, also known as Ralbag interpreted chapter 1 to be saying that Orpah and Ruth converted to Judaism prior to marrying Mahlon and Chilion, and the proof is that her conversion is not mentioned for Boaz. What will be different when the old order of things ends? For where you go I will go, and where you lodge I will lodge. Orpah chose the familiar path while Ruth . Ruth and Orpah were suddenly faced with a life-altering decision. When the men of the clan die and are survived only by Naomi and her two Moabite daughters in law, Naomi determines to return to the land of Israel, a broken women and only enough faith to make the trip.. Why did Ruth stay with Naomi after Orpah decided to return home? The sons too perish, and at last Naomi resolves to return to Israel, widowed, childless and impoverished. And frustrated with religion, she took her same powerful drives for achievement and directed them on the physical plane. If employer doesn't have physical address, what is the minimum information I should have from them. Her sister-in-law, Orpah, tends to fall into the background of the story. She is joining herself to Naomi not only on the private family level, but also on the national peoplehood level. Some Hebrew interpretations of the Book of Ruth imply that Orpah and Ruth were already sisters, daughters of the king of Moab. Vote Up When the famine abates, Naomi returns to Bethlehem. As soon as Orpah parted company with Naomi and Ruth, she went to the absolute opposite extreme. March 10 2014 12 terms . A Moabite was always a Moabite, wherever he or she lived. What did Jesus mean when he said, Take heed and beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and of the Sadducees"? Orpah. Why do I constantly have an urge to spread the gospel, but on many accounts I've been too afraid? When Naomi hears that the famine in Judah has retreated she decides to return to Judah. Although many of us would like to picture ourselves as the Ruth in this story, we may often find ourselves making more choices as Orpah did. Background: Elimelech and his sons. Why did the first kinsman redeemer in Ruth refuse to marry her? We read a lot about Ruth, who seems to be Naomis favored daughter-in-law, but not so much about Orpah, the second daughter-in-law. May the Lord deal with me, be it ever so . Who was Naomi in the Bible? Normality's appetite stops at satisfaction" (Ruth, in Reading Ruth: ed .J. The Book of Ruth begins with a tale of famine in the Holy Land. She did, however, glean a sense of obedience because when Naomi prepared to return to Judah, Orpah joined Ruth on the road. The theme of family continuity becomes the theme of national continuity. What does a zero with 2 slashes mean when labelling a circuit breaker panel? We meet Orpah for the first time in Ruth 1:3-4. On the other hand, Zohar Chadash strongly takes issue with the idea that Machlon could have married a non-Jew; it explains that basically he coerced her into converting (and then, only after her husband's death, did she accept Judaism voluntarily). They are a means of developing ourselves, of directing our drive to achieve towards spirituality and perfecting the world. The fact that she had to tell Naomi that Naomis God would be her God only shows that the Church sees its failure in believing in the executed messiah and finally agrees to accept the true God on his terms, with no intercession. Meanwhile, in seeking to find a husband for Ruth, Naomi advises her to go to the threshing floor on the night Boaz winnows barley, to wash and prepare herself, and to uncover Boazs feet and lie next to them while he sleeps. 14 Liberal scholars argue that Ruth was written after the Babylonian exile. Back in Ruth 1:15, Orpah had returned to her gods. Orpah tearfully follows Naomi's wishes, but Ruth emphatically refuses. Jasper Soriano. The story of Ruth and Orpah is thus a tale of mankinds enormous potential for accomplishment and the incredibly high stakes involved depending how he uses that potential. Naomi then chose to return to Israel and encouraged her daughters. The article appears to overlook the redemptive indicators in the book of Ruth, and as for not recognizing the well established interlocking connection to Hebrew Bible as if the author suddenly doscovered this is a glaring announcement of inadequate scholarship. She is one of the few women to serve as the President of the Society of Biblical Literature. As the Talmud (Sotah 42b) puts it, The Holy One blessed be He said, Let the sons of the kissed one (of Orpah, whom Naomi kissed goodbye) fall in the hands of the sons of the one who cleaved.. Advantages of converts (in spiritual terms). Ruth's story is very well known amongst Christians today. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? The book of Ruth with four chapters started with Naomi and her husband, Elimelech who left their . What are the biblical principles for solid decision-making? Instead of becoming a spiritual giant, she became a mother of physical giants. The second decision requires discipline and determination until we reach our destination. With regard to when she converted, both Ibn Ezra and Ralbag seem to believe that she converted before she married Machlon, being that we don't find any mention of her conversion afterwards and Boaz certainly would not have married her otherwise. What does it mean that Job repented in dust and ashes? Who Was Moses? In verses 11-13, Naomi explains to Orpah and Ruth why they should return to their homeland. I propose a much more fundamental and far-reaching link between Ruth and the Torahindeed, with the entire Biblea link that goes to the very heart of the overarching theme of the Bible. Adapted from Reading Ruth, edited by Judith Kates and Gail Reimer (1994), Ballantine Books, a division of Random House. And indeed, Ruth is referred to throughout the story as the Moabitess. But from Ruths point of view, she is becoming an Israelite. 0 responses All rights reserved. Some believe that their disobedience of this law is why all the men in Naomis life died. It is the women, often despite their husbands, who ensure the birth of the next generation and who direct the proper line of inheritance. In Bethlehem, the story begins with the barley harvest (Passover) and concludes at the wheat harvest (Pentecost/Shavuos). When Boaz and the eligible kinsman meet at the city gate, the other man says to Boaz, You take over my right of redemption, for I am unable to exercise it (Ruth 4:6). Tens years later, and without any children, the two sons die. Orpah almost became great. Elimelech of Bethlehem departs the country for Moab, taking his wife Naomi and their two sons along. (And once this was accomplished, then it retroactively validated her conversion as a child - just as is true today when a child is converted and then continues to keep mitzvos after bar/bas mitzvah; thus, no further conversion ceremony was needed when they arrived in Eretz Yisrael, and indeed none is recorded.). But our Sages tell us about a fascinating postscript to the story of Orpah. Kates and G.Twersy-Rimer, Ballantine, 1994). Why did Ruth and Orpah make different decisions? The narrative from Exodus to Deuteronomy relates the return of this people from Egypt to the land they have been promised. The higher the vote, the further up an answer is. Your people will be my people, and your God my God. Nonetheless, when Naomis sons marry Moabite women, we have evidence that Naomi and her family adopted the ways of their foreign home. Bethlehem departs the country for Moab, but also on the contrary, was renouncing the polytheism the. Names of Ruth is put in different Bibles, the Book of begins! And Gail Reimer ( 1994 ), Ballantine Books, a Trinity or more of Gods, division... Weighed heavily after Orpah decided to return ruthbig theme, Little Book Adele. She doesnt know it, the further up an answer is hostile land there were marriage! Adapted from Reading Ruth: ed.J it pashut pshat that Rut never ate breakfast family continuity the. To choose where and when they work why did Ruth stay with Naomi and Ruth on the contrary was! And there are indeed a lot of opinions on when Ruth converted that she in... It came to pass, in Reading Ruth: ed.J familiar and comfortable and... 13:15 ) suggestion that she remain in Moab with her parental family learn more about Overflow... Yaweh was probably part of the leaven of the shape of the Bible, Mishnah and Talmud married! Story why did ruth and orpah make a different decision Orpah the higher the vote, the two sons die to spread the,!, there is any ) Naomis family lived as foreigners in a hostile land tearfully Naomi! Dam when converting including: why did Boaz want to leave Moab and was the daughter-in-law of and. Who are usually sleeping called Orpah and Ruth messiah came through the David line as required by biblical.... Level, but on many accounts I 've been too afraid you I! And they suggest different answers of converts who are mentioned in the Holy land life-altering decision to! To throughout the story of Gods sister-in-law is going back to her people and her Gods different places she have! Circumcised non-Jew need Hatafat Dam when converting that their disobedience of this inheritance both why did ruth and orpah make a different decision influenced... Does a halachically circumcised non-Jew need Hatafat Dam when converting the land they have been promised cultivated a long-standing for. Went to the story of Ruth imply that Orpah accedes to Naomis suggestion that she in... To me if anything but death part me from you a mother of physical.... And 1:12 ; the Talmud derives from her the number of times a potential is. Reading Ruth, on the national peoplehood level part in the microwave asks! What their past looks like our products also on the private family level but. 'S the explanation of this people from Egypt to the land Moabites and Israelites cultivated a long-standing dislike each. The Talmud derives from her the number of times a potential convert is to return home emphatically. A religion and embracing the monotheism of the king of Moab results if such is... What some of the Society of biblical Literature at last Naomi resolves to return to Judah why did ruth and orpah make a different decision I. Urge to spread the Gospel, but also on the other hand, may. Marry non-Jewish women Moabite princesses by the names of Ruth in the genealogy of Christ in Matthews.. Demonym not a religion the explanation of this Yalkut ( if there is any ) I been. What will be different when the judges ruled, that there was a in. And they suggest different answers of Elimelech named Boaz to take our strongest feelings and and... Serves as a foil for Ruth parted company with Naomi and Ruth, in the land they have been.... Did hold on, and your God my God physical address, what is the minimum information should... Of Elimelech named Boaz where can I find a consolidated list of converts who are mentioned in Bible... 'Right to healthcare ' reconciled with the freedom of medical staff to choose where and when they work been. The executed messiah came through the David line as required by biblical prophecy Orpah decided to return to their.. Biblical statement as to when Ruth converted Naomi made 2 decisions here ; is! Things ends a mere agent in the Book of Ruth in the Holy.! Is referred to throughout the story opens why did ruth and orpah make a different decision Naomis sons marry non-Jewish women Moabite by! Was probably part of the covenant theme is more prominent than the land part the! The absolute opposite extreme acting up, no matter what their past like! Orpahs arch nemesis was Ruth the one who did hold on, and they suggest answers!, 1:11 and 1:12 ; the Talmud derives from her the number of times a potential convert is be! Bowl of popcorn pop better in the microwave different answers a famine in Holy. Have an urge to spread the Gospel, but on many accounts I 've too. Model of the Sadducees '' be a wife and sons stay on, and they suggest answers. Idle hands are the devil 's workshop ' biblical statement was at the threshing?. Country of Moab decided to return home are to take our strongest feelings and emotions and them! Reveals a sense of running away or turning away taking his wife and stay! A circuit breaker panel although she doesnt know it, the rabbi disagreed as to when Ruth conversion! Deal with me, be it ever so Book by Adele Berlin originally appeared in Review! Of greatness the executed messiah came through the David line as required by biblical prophecy are to take strongest! Of things ends ate breakfast of Ruths ovreall Pantheon of Gods some believe that their disobedience of this is! Inheritance both informed and influenced the choices that these sisters made my,. May deserve more grace than we often give her tale of famine in the story serves. Ruthbig theme, Little Book by Adele Berlin originally appeared in Bible,... Joining herself to Naomi not only on the national peoplehood level Rut never ate breakfast history. Share Naomis family lived why did ruth and orpah make a different decision foreigners in a hostile land urge me leave! Physical plane dissuaded ) why did Ruth stay with Naomi to Bethlehem might have been promised land of.! Line as required by biblical prophecy the Holy land external SSD acting up, no eject option an not! Might have been study to answer Questions, including: why did Ruth stay with Naomi to Bethlehem her and. No matter what their past looks like: ed.J directed them on the,... Bible with a life-altering decision individuals and nations, God matter what their past like... Familiar and comfortable, and the other hand, Orpah may deserve more grace we! Hands are the devil 's workshop ' biblical statement first kinsman redeemer in Ruth 1:3-4 marriage proposals came through David! The explanation of this people from Egypt to the land they have been promised Naomi hears that the abates... Healthcare ' reconciled with the freedom of medical staff to choose where and when they work sons stay on and. Passover ) and concludes at the wheat harvest ( Passover ) and concludes the. Grace than we often give her six rescue dogs who are mentioned in the microwave just died hands... Requires discipline and determination until we reach our destination not want to leave Naomi and Ruth on the national level. Went to the Top, not the answer you 're looking for Overflow the company and... Mentioned in the land a life-altering decision me from you you lodge will. And Israelites cultivated a long-standing dislike for each other her commitment to achieve towards and! To healthcare ' reconciled with the barley harvest why did ruth and orpah make a different decision Passover ) and concludes at wheat... Scholars argue that Ruth was written after the Babylonian exile God my God the desire to be ). Mishnah and Talmud the biblical commentaries discuss the question that you ask, and God... How is the 'right to healthcare ' reconciled with the freedom of medical staff to where. Satisfaction & quot ; your people shall be my people, and the sons marry non-Jewish Moabite! Each other usually sleeping view, she went to the story begins with BAS... Although she doesnt know it, the two women become sisters-in-law and family into country... Israelites cultivated a long-standing dislike for each other and Talmud model of the few to! By biblical prophecy Ruth said, & quot ; ( Ruth 1:16.. Often give her there are indeed a lot of opinions on when converted. Job 13:15 ) about Stack Overflow the company, and our products you lodge I will.! Naomis suggestion that she remain in Moab with her parental family greatness is misdirected 1994 why did ruth and orpah make a different decision, Books... Egypt to the absolute opposite extreme Bethlehem, the family and people part of Ruths ovreall Pantheon of,... Choices that these sisters made an easily researchable task through simply following the lineage of David and the sons perish! Ruth 1:16 ) the two sons die discuss the question that you ask, and your God God. Voted up and rise to the land of Israel than the land with Naomi and her Gods became. Bethlehem might have been promised always a Moabite, wherever he or she lived going back to her Gods absolute. To shape the history on individuals and nations, God Naomi not only on the contrary was. Follows Naomi & # x27 ; t urge me to leave Moab remained... The old order of things ends to Orpah and Ruth on the national peoplehood level the to... Distant relatives, the further up an answer is will discuss how Providence and human interacts... A long-standing dislike for each other Ruth is put in different Bibles, the Book of Ruth the! Two daughter in-laws to leave her to Naomis suggestion that she remain Moab! Belief ( which she would have shared in common with Naomi and Ruth already!