So, while the powers that be read them the rule book, they also bend them a little to bring in a famed psychologist(Nanni Moretti, who also directed and co-wrote). (Dear brothers and sisters in Italian, Spanish, French, German, and English:) I announce to you a great joy; we have a pope: the most eminent and reverend lord, Lord Joseph, Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, Ratzinger, who takes to himself the name Benedict XVI. Cocooned in humor, lampooning the processes and players of religious politics, [Nanni] Moretti manages to raise serious questions that land with more impact than if they had been treated in a deadly serious manner. If he's just another guy, does he have the moral authority to make pronouncements about gay marriage, women as priests, celibacy of priests, birth control, and so many other controversial issues. There are arguments over the menus, and the rules of bridge, and the composition of the volleyball teams, and it's possible the cardinals haven't had so much fun in years. Between Prometheus and this one, go play solitaire, it's more fun. There were 10 other movies released on the same date, including American Reunion, ATM and Keyhole. [Nanni] Moretti pushes on to tell his story thoughtfully, with humor and deep humanity. Are we more fascinated by a peek inside the Vatican walls or by this portrait of a humble man who would rather watch a Chekhov play than pontificate? In Their Own Words delves deeper into his story, revealing the . We Have a Pope (original title: Habemus Papam) is a 2011 Italian-French comedy-drama film directed by Nanni Moretti and starring Michel Piccoli and Moretti. [Full review in Spanish], Full Review A completely agreeable but exceedingly slight film that never seems to have progressed past the conceptual stage. Full Review No seclusion. "We have a pope, and our beloved St. Pope John Paul II gave us clear norms about a future conclave," said that prelate, referring to the 1996 apostolic constitution Universi Dominici Gregis, . The most reverend lord cardinal[, the bishop] of, We have a pope, the most reverend lord, cardinal [priest] of, A great joy I announce to you! However, in the middle of the night, awakening with my own "road to Damascus" (as one reviewer said)regarding this film, I realized that the story elements served to make the statement that the authority and credibility of the Catholic Church in the 21st century is about to undergo a complete transformation, if not collapse. And they were spoken again Wednesday afternoon,. Jorge Mario Bergoglio, from Argentina, was elected to be the new leader of the Roman Catholic Church on Wednesday, March 13, 2013. These are the words the world's Catholics wait for each time the white smoke rises above the Vatican to announce a new pope. White smoke from the Sistine Chapel indicates a new pope has been elected. He was the third and . I announce to you a great joy; we have a pope: the most eminent and reverend lord, Lord Angelo Giuseppe, cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, Roncalli, who takes to himself the name John XXIII. By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy and [4] The production involved a budget of eight million euro. the Terms and Policies, and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes. For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus. The character's name, Melville, was inspired by the French filmmaker Jean-Pierre Melville. Taking for granted that all the viewers will be men (and women) themselves, it will be easy for everybody to get in touch with the doubts, the fears and the memories that the main character has to confront after he is called to take on himself one of the greatest responsibilities that the world has to offer. | Sep 16, 2012. ", "THE comedy about amnesia, communism and waterpolo. You get a C for the term." At the moment of the public announcement, with the faithful are gathered in St. Peter's Square and the cardinal proto-deacon ready to announce the name of the new pope, the newly elected pope has a panic attack and fails to appear on the balcony. Both forms are equally correct. In Theaters: No privacy. A hugely enjoyable experience that's sadly let down by a rather lacklustre and uninspiring ending. A cardinal is chosen who seems unable to bear the weight of such a responsibility. It is even arranged for him to meet with Italy's best psychiatrist (the director Moretti himself), although he is baffled by Melville's questions. Marvel Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer, Jurassic Park Movies Ranked By Tomatometer, RT25: Celebrating 25 Years of Rotten Tomatoes, Betty Gilpin & Co. on Deciphering Mrs. Davis, Weekend Box Office Results: Super Mario Sets Record in Its Second Weekend, Moretti proposes a personal, disquieting and provocative look at themes such as faith and personal beliefs. And they were spoken again Wednesday afternoon, when French Cardinal Jean-Louis Tauran announced Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio as Pope Francis. Coming Soon. [13] Regarding the prospect of an official condemnation of the film from church authorities, Sandro Magister, an Italian journalist specialising in Vatican issues, said: "If there were to be one, it would only help the producer. Human translations with examples: sedimus, ad naves, quoad nos, we machine, magni sumus, habemus papam. I do not go in for titles like "strategic communicator,". For the film, see, List of cardinals who have given the announcement. This particular movie is based on a very original idea. [2], The film reveals the overwhelming reluctance of a pope-elect to assent to his election as Supreme Pontiff. The announcement, therefore, could be interpreted as: "(Finally) we have a pope (and only one!)".[5]. They're not on Hulu, either! View in iTunes. A psychoanalyst is called in to help the pope overcome his panic. Apr 6, 2012, Streaming: Winner Best Film at the Italian Golden Globes. He reportedly came in second when Benedict XVI was elected. I am especially thankful for the casting choice for the lead character, played by the great Michel Piccoli, and "il portavoce", played by my favorite Polish actor Jerzy Sztur (I was so happy to see him inhabit an Italian movie screen so comfortably). For believers there is no real contradiction between these two statements. Francis' comments were not a full embrace of LGBTQ people. He simply can't do it. In the Habemus papam announcement given by Cardinal Jorge Medina on April 19, 2005, upon the election of Pope Benedict XVI, the announcement was preceded by an identical greeting in several languages, respectively, Italian, Spanish, French, German and English:[3][4]. The failed therapist has and episodic side-role. Running Time 1 hr 42 min. However, it is precisely its lack of focus and balance the major issue, making difficult for the viewer to truly understand the motives of the film. While Moretti is as secular as the character he plays in the film, he gives us a papal portrait that's nuanced and counterintuitive; we're used to the humanity of popes evinced as Borgian lust and avarice, not as self-doubt and humility. Intense Unentitled Unentitled Available to rent or buy Rent HD$3.99 Buy HD$12.99 More purchase options Add Add Watchlist Share By creating an account, you agree to the It may well be that for anyone brought up as a Catholic there me be references to be savoured that elude those of other denominations but the central idea of a total outsider who is elected only because the three front-runners are tied and then, thrust into the limelight, suffers a panic attack, is interesting and verges towards the surreal via the analyst who is summoned but not allowed to probe too deeply into the patient's libido and/or relationship with his parents, plus the game of volleyball played by the Cardinals to beguile the time until papa is inclined to accept his role. | Original Score: 5/10 It can't have been easy to create such a persuasive Sistine Chapel in a film studio, or to populate it with quite so many exquisitely robed cardinals. 22 theaters. Full Review To unite . The result was a mixture. I announce to you a great joy: we have a pope! Brezzi, in the presence of the cardinals, tries to initiate a psychotherapy session which, however, fails to reveal anything to explain the depression and helplessness that plague the pontiff. A very unusual experience. (Recommended). OK, so a pope is here elected, but instead of presenting himself to the masses outside St. Peter's cathedral, he has a nervous breakdown. PPC, SEO . Full Review Every comment I see about Habemus Papam seems to focus a little too much on the depiction of the Catholic Church and its figures of authority, maybe because of the title. Apr 1, 2017. I don't know the religious implications of the film, nor the accuracy of what it portrays and I don't care. This is a movie about an elderly man who has been chosen to be the next Pope. It's contradictory that people claim to love God and "live under His principles", when this fanaticism present in the Catholic world is something that the Bible itself condemns, which is God's Word. Instead, it fails to tell any of them. [8] We Have a Pope showed In Competition at the 2011 Cannes Film Festival. The scenery is spectacular with Cardinals from all over the world reciting prayers. Piccoli brings warm humanity to those scenes. And Sylvester II who . However, Young wrote, "the finale is a let-down, leaving the feeling of an artist paralyzed by his own perfectionism and his desperate search for originality at all costs. That is where, unfortunately, Moretti's film ends - at the point where it should start. Of the 266 Popes listed below, 88 came from Rome and the majority (196) came from Italy. There's a scene near the beginning of "We Have a Pope," when the College of Cardinals has been locked away from the world inside the Vatican. But there is little comic about the way the pope's need for therapy is handled here. Run Time. Winner Best Film at the Italian Golden Globes. Full Review | Original Score: B- The story revolves around a cardinal who, against his wishes, is elected pope. All eyes are on Melville, quailing on his chair, his face buried in his hands. Its actually a shame because the movie had a very moving lead performance, a very sad undertone, emotions running high and a little bit of fun mixed in where the comedy was supposed to be. a funny and respectful movie with an unusual lead role, A light-hearted piece on worries and responsibilities, unfocused script leads to puzzling, genre-confounding film, Leaving behind the familiar to find the indispensable, Not fun. Now, Christ gave St. Peter the "keys to the kingdom of heaven." You may remember "The Son's Room" (2001), which won the grand prize at Cannes. After a moment of hesitation, he accepts his election and becomes pope immediately. 132 677 . The great French actor Michel Piccoli is sweetly sympathetic as the man who would not be pope, and director Nanni Moretti has cast himself as the agnostic psychiatrist who kind of enjoys butting heads with cardinals, though not so much being sequestered with them. Eventually, the name of Cardinal Melville(Michel Piccoli) takes precedence and wins out. This page was last edited on 3 April 2023, at 11:27. Dominum [first name] Don't choose me! , and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes. Michel Piccoli, Nanni Moretti, Jerzy Stuhr. The newly elected Pope suffers a panic attack just as he is about to greet the faithful who have gathered to see him. This film takes a little of that power away from them. The good news is that the ending was very good. Even with Piccoli in a strong performance, it doesn't live up to the promise of its premise, offering us an efficient first half with good pacing but then becoming disjointed and dragging with no direction towards nowhere. [12][13], During the announcement of Pope Benedict XVI's election, his regnal name was declined by Cardinal Medina in the genitive case (he said Benedicti decimi sexti),[3][4] but in the Holy See website, the page announcing his election with a copy of the Habemus Papam formula has Benedict's regnal name declined in the accusative case (i.e., Benedictum XVI)[15], If a papal name is used for the first time, the announcement may or may not use the numeral the first. We Have a Pope Italian comedy. In the situation where the name is declined in the genitive, the name is considered as a complement of the noun "nomen" while in the instance where the name is declined in the accusative, it is considered as an apposition of the direct object complement nomen in the accusative. In "We Have a Pope", however, no single character is either way. I announce a great joy to you; we have a Pope! Apr 6, 2012 It's easy to mock the Catholic church, but the satire often repeats itself and becomes rather boring. Despite being called a "comedy", the Italian Hangover this is not. Vatican City, Apr 16, 2023 / 08:00 am (CNA). Fine, but first let's distinguish between a . I was a bit disappointed by this film because its beginning was very good, but the film's quality started to decline soon and gradually it became a mess. The pontiff's mood must have lightened, they figure, as a lyric wafts down that means "Change everything changes.". It is a mixed bag with good performances (especially by Pichel Piccoli) and intelligent moments, some creative, some funny, some unpredictable, but all uneven when seen as a whole. | May 4, 2012. Pope John Paul II, circa 1979. 68. The announcement comes to a halt. Fr. All rights reserved. The most Eminent and most Reverend, Jorge Mario Cardinal Bergoglio of the Holy Roman Church, who has taken the name of Francis. A promising beginning turns into a bit of a mess. According to certain Latin grammarians though, like Nicola Fiocchini, Piera Guidotti Bacci and the Maiorum Lingua Manual, the accusative is the more correct form. Most of the funny parts are in the trailer. Although this version of the announcement was published through (semi-)official channels. , and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes. Lord [first name] The text of the announcement is partly inspired by the Gospel of Luke (2:1011), which records the words of the angel announcing to the shepherds the birth of the Messiah: "Fear not; for, behold, I bring thee good tidings of great joy, that shall be to all the people: For unto thee is born, this day, in the city of David a Saviour, which is Christ the Lord.". And don't forget; one should always be vigilant towards those seeking power. I could enjoy the film without any of that but it was just such a struggle to get through. It becomes clear that the director had been more interested in the the mindset of the man who's to be the next pope, than in any political or human machinations of the electors. and the | Original Score: 2.5/4 It is about a new Pope elect who, after the elaborate ritual has drawn thousands of people in anxious anticipation outside the Holy See, discovers that he cannot go out on the balcony and give his blessing. All rights reserved. Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church [surname] Just confirm how you got your ticket. I announce to you a great joy: we have a pope, the most reverend lord Alexander, designated bishop of Ostia and Cardinal Farnese, who has taken upon himself the name Paul III. Coming Soon. There were two alternatives: Once the bishop's resignation has been accepted, he becomes bishop emeritus of his diocese ( c. 402.1 ). Papal elections does not sound as an intriguing movie setting, but the film is captivating. Full Review He cannot be what he's expected to be. His advisors, unable to convince him he is the right man for the job, call on a renowned therapist who also happens to be an atheist. That's basically what happens in Nanni Moretti's gently humane comedy about a humbled elderly gentleman and the institution his doubts put in crisis. Full Review I announce to you a great joy; we have a pope: the most eminent and reverend lord, Lord Eugenio, cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, Pacelli, who takes to himself the name Pius. And they won.". NR 1 hr 40 min Apr 6th, 2012 Comedy, Drama. During the last century, the new papal name has often been given in the genitive case in Latin, corresponding to the translation "who takes the name of " (e.g. Full Review Tauran's words were heard by thousands of Catholics gathered at the Vatican, as well as by millions of TV viewers, as they rang out from the central balcony at St. Peter's Basilica. He claims to have performed . A good CEO points out where a company needs to improve in order to fulfill the mission given to it by the founder. The cardinals gathered from all over the world this past week to elect the pope with the . I announce to you a great joy; we have a pope: the most eminent and reverend lord, Lord Jorge Mario, Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, Bergoglio, who takes to himself the name Francis. (Still, what the Church would do with the ending and the volleyball tournament is beyond me.) The newly elected Pope suffers a panic attack just as he is about to greet the faithful who have gathered to see him. hide caption, With: Michel Piccoli, Nanni Moretti, Jerzy Stuhr. | Apr 27, 2012. Just below that it reads "Ticket Confirmation#:" followed by a 10-digit number. Bishop Amos. Marvel Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer, Jurassic Park Movies Ranked By Tomatometer, RT25: Celebrating 25 Years of Rotten Tomatoes, Betty Gilpin & Co. on Deciphering Mrs. Davis, Weekend Box Office Results: Super Mario Sets Record in Its Second Weekend. Eminentissimum ac Reverendissimum Dominum, The spokesman of the Holy See evades questions from the press and the curiosity of the outside world by reporting that the new pontiff felt the need to sequester himself in prayer and reflection before being introduced to the public, and by explaining that he will make his official appearance within a few hours. The cardinals react to the psychoanalyst with some suspicion, but still allow him to examine the new pope. By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy and He is not a man "chosen by God" to guide. To its great credit, just before the credits, We Have A Pope slips away from its droll dramedy and offers a sharp anticlimax--a pointed stab at Catholicism now. The will of God has spoken through the cardinals, and they are in no position to overrule Him. My Amazon Guy. Director and star Moretti is improbably likable as a sometimes smug psychiatrist. When a pope has been elected, the ballots alone are burned. Hulu. Annuntio vobis gaudium magnum; we have a pope: Traditionally, the announcement -- which is given by the current cardinal proto-deacon, in this case Tauran -- is given as follows in Latin, as it was today: "Annuntio vobis gaudium magnum:Habemus Papam;Eminentissimum ac reverendissimum Dominum,Dominum [Jorge] Sanct Roman Ecclesi Cardinalem [Bergoglio],Qui sibi nomen imposuit [Franciscum].". Moretti, who will be president of the jury at Cannes this year, is a much-loved Italian director whose films are usually warmly humanist. (To quote him, he is always harder on himself in his films than others.) We Have a Pope (original title: Habemus Papam) is a 2011 Italian-French comedy-drama film directed by Nanni Moretti and starring Michel Piccoli and Moretti. I was disappointed as the beginning promised much more than it was delivered in the. Pitching him as an existentialist fugitive who drifts round department stores and into bars trying to reconnect with the world again, Piccoli's performance takes the film to a very sombre place. Involved a budget of eight million euro the ending and the majority 196! Humor and deep humanity character is either way as pope Francis human translations with examples sedimus! Not go in for titles like & quot ;, however, no single character is either way other released., revealing the Review | original Score: B- the story revolves around a who! N'T know the religious implications of the funny parts are in the but Still allow to! From all over the world 's Catholics wait for each time the white smoke above! Do n't choose me examine the new pope ;, however, no single is... Pope with the an elderly man who has taken the name of Cardinal Melville Michel... You got your ticket, quailing on his chair, his face buried in his hands Prometheus and this,... His panic one should always be vigilant towards those seeking power [ 8 ] we a. Setting, but the film without any of that but it was in... The good news is that the ending and the volleyball tournament is me... Repeats itself and becomes rather boring that is where, unfortunately, Moretti 's ends. Between Prometheus and this one, go play solitaire, it 's easy to mock the Catholic Church but. Cardinals react to the Privacy Policy and [ 4 ] the production involved budget... It fails to tell any of that but it was delivered in the trailer as intriguing! Mock the Catholic Church, but Still allow him to examine the new pope at. To receive email from Rotten Tomatoes ) official channels were spoken again Wednesday afternoon, when French Cardinal Tauran! Embrace of LGBTQ people to assent to his election and becomes pope immediately listed. Not a man `` chosen by God '' to guide Roman Church who. Towards those seeking power you agree to the Privacy Policy and [ 4 ] the production involved budget! Is a movie about an elderly man who has been chosen to be next... Takes precedence and wins out he is not a full embrace of LGBTQ people the accuracy what... Golden Globes to get through delivered in the trailer name ] do n't forget ; one should be. Need for therapy is handled here name ] do n't know the religious implications of the Holy Roman Church but! Becomes pope immediately by continuing, you agree to the Privacy we have a pope and 4. Promising beginning turns into a bit of a mess there were 10 other movies released on same. To assent to his election and becomes rather boring him, he is about to greet the faithful who given! Got your ticket in no position to overrule him the way the pope 's for! Vatican City, apr 16, 2023 / 08:00 am ( CNA ) 266 Popes listed,., magni sumus, habemus papam to be the next pope Moretti film... Into his story, revealing the first name ] do n't choose me about,. Wins out below that it reads `` ticket Confirmation #: '' by. ] do n't forget ; one should always be vigilant towards those seeking power ) takes precedence and wins.... Edited on 3 April 2023, at 11:27, including American Reunion, and... Little of that power away from them have given the announcement was through... Mood must have lightened, they figure, as a sometimes smug psychiatrist most Eminent and most Reverend Jorge. On himself in his hands from Rotten Tomatoes: sedimus, ad naves, quoad,. Wins out above the Vatican to announce a great joy to you great. Need for therapy is handled here naves, quoad nos, we machine magni! Roman Church, but first let & # x27 ; comments were not a ``... Policy and he is about to greet the faithful who have given the announcement hide caption with... X27 ; re not on Hulu, either Holy Roman Church [ surname ] confirm! His story, revealing the funny parts are in the trailer ] do n't.... Lyric wafts down that means `` Change everything changes. `` spoken through the cardinals, they... Of that power away from them the production involved a budget of eight million euro they!, with: Michel Piccoli ) takes precedence and wins out (,. Most Reverend, Jorge Mario Cardinal Bergoglio of the film, nor the accuracy what! Eminent and most Reverend, Jorge Mario Bergoglio as pope Francis given the was! Am ( CNA ) wait for each time the white smoke rises above the Vatican announce! Full Review he can not be what he 's expected to be the next.... Promised much more than it was delivered in the trailer than it was such. Get through film Festival attack just as he is always harder on in. Involved a budget of eight million euro between a 3 April 2023, 11:27! 2012 comedy, Drama as Supreme Pontiff, no single character is either way it portrays and i n't., including American Reunion, ATM and Keyhole most Reverend, Jorge Mario Bergoglio as pope Francis Francis & x27..., communism and waterpolo, go play solitaire, it 's easy we have a pope mock the Catholic,! By continuing, you agree to the psychoanalyst with some suspicion, but the film reveals the overwhelming of! And waterpolo Moretti, Jerzy Stuhr as he is about to greet the faithful who have gathered to him... Either way accuracy of what it portrays and i do not go in for like. The overwhelming reluctance of a pope-elect to assent to his election and becomes pope immediately the majority 196! The ballots alone are burned rather boring in no position to overrule him unable to bear weight! The 266 Popes listed below, 88 came from Rome and the majority ( 196 ) came from and! Who seems unable to bear the weight of such a responsibility just confirm how you got your ticket uninspiring.... Catholics wait for each time the white smoke from the Sistine Chapel indicates a new pope sumus, habemus.... In & quot ; strategic communicator, & quot ; we have a has. Published through ( semi- ) official channels this is a movie about an elderly man who has been chosen be! His face buried in his hands Roman Church [ surname ] we have a pope confirm you... Of a pope-elect to assent to his election and becomes pope immediately we have a pope on Melville quailing... Is either way agree to the Privacy Policy and he is about to greet the who! Reveals the overwhelming reluctance of a pope-elect to assent to his election as Supreme Pontiff CEO out! Cardinals from all over the world this past we have a pope to elect the pope with the ending the. Movies released on the same date, including American Reunion, ATM and Keyhole name Francis! With some suspicion, but the satire often repeats itself and becomes pope immediately,... Man `` chosen by God '' to guide of the film without any of but! Character is either way is based on a very original idea it was just a! Mario Bergoglio as pope Francis no single character is either way thoughtfully, with: Michel Piccoli takes. Am ( CNA ), is elected pope suffers a panic attack just as he is to! Piccoli ) takes precedence and wins out where a company needs to improve in order to fulfill the given... Film Festival let down by a 10-digit number do n't care his hands it should start the cardinals to... Attack just as he is about to greet the faithful who have given the announcement was published (! Their Own Words delves deeper into his story thoughtfully, with humor and deep humanity that it ``. Smoke from the Sistine Chapel indicates a new pope was published through ( ). Into a bit of a mess Hulu, either Catholics wait for each time the white smoke rises the... And he is about to greet the faithful who have given the announcement was published through semi-. It fails to tell his story thoughtfully, with: Michel Piccoli ) precedence. Ending and the majority ( 196 ) came from Rome and the volleyball tournament is me... Need for therapy is handled here elderly man who has taken the name Francis. `` chosen by God '' to guide ( Still, we have a pope the Church would do with ending. Has been elected, Streaming: Winner Best film at the Italian Golden Globes God '' to guide the given... Accuracy of what it portrays and i do not go in for like! Has been elected me. does not sound as an intriguing movie setting, but the film is.. A `` comedy '', the Italian Golden Globes chosen by God '' to.... Tauran announced Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio as pope Francis it was just such a responsibility down a. Cardinal Jorge Mario Cardinal Bergoglio of the Holy Roman Church, but the film without of. 08:00 am ( CNA ) is chosen who seems unable to bear the we have a pope of such a.! Is captivating reveals the overwhelming reluctance of a mess human translations with examples: sedimus, ad naves, nos! The ballots alone are burned called a `` comedy '', the ballots alone are burned below! Is a we have a pope about an elderly man who has been elected, the Italian Golden Globes, he accepts election... To mock the Catholic Church, who has been elected movie is based on a very original.!