There is also a ruler for measuring your fish as you catch them. One of its more popular offerings, the YETI Roadie 24 (a replacement for the now-discontinued . Yeti claims this cooler is "30% better thermally than its legendary predecessor", the Roadie 20. Additionally, the BMX cooler features oversized hinges and stainless steel screws that are extremely durable. Meanwhile, Igloo's 36oz Legacy Growler costs only $20.99 and has the added bonus of being Star Wars themed. Genius. Also, don't forget to check out our handy dandy video buying guide for coolers with Andrew Gebhart. The IMX coolers are their most durable and also feature Ultratherm insulation for the brands longest ice retention. We found that, up until the 5th day, there was still plenty of ice left in the ice chest, even when ambient temperatures were very high. But in the big picture, if you want stuff to stay cold, you literally cannot beat Cabela's Polar Cap option. Smart home technology and wireless connectivity, production delays and decidedly unhappy customers, Best Kitchen Gifts for a Home Cook or Foodie, The 5 Best Tea Subscriptions to Gift This Year, Read our Magellan Outdoors Dual Open 20qt Cooler review, Amazon Commercial Rotomolded Cooler, 20qt, Yeti Hopper Backflip 24 Insulated Backpack Cooler, Coleman 24-Can Party Stacker Portable Cooler, Xspec 60 Quart Roto Molded High Performance Cooler, Igloo Trailmate Journey 70qt All-Terrain Cooler, the comments on the Infinite Cooler's Indiegogo campaign, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, 10 years product testing experience with the CNET Home team. And its remarkably durable for a softshell cooler the exterior of the Hopper is resistant to punctures, abrasions, mildew, and UV rays, making it tough enough for any adventure. Performance is important, but design matters, too -- and sometimes, it's a deal-breaker. We thought that seemed a bit expensive for a cooler so we put it head-to-head. I think that the priciest cooler they make is about $250, which is virtually the starting price for most Yeti coolers. And can any of the cheaper models keep up? This cooler also features a pair of wheels and a telescopic wheel handle, for easy transport even at full capacity. While you're at it, Magellan tosses in a couple of bottle openers, a metal reinforced lock area and a drain plug. I also renovate, flip and build houses in my 'spare' time. The Tundra Haul is no different. The swinging joints on either side that attach the top handle also have integrated slots that function as tie-down attachment points. On the other hand, if you want a decent cooler that has some interesting gimmicky features, you might just enjoy the Igloo coolers more. There are pros and cons to both Yeti and Igloo coolers, so I wont say that one is always better than the other. It has a massive capacity of up to 45 cans of beer, which is really good. Yeti vs Igloo: price Igloo's IMX 70 is priced at $250, whereas the Tundra 65 will set you back a cool $375.00 (400.00), so it's clear that the additional quality comes at a price. To do that, I started with a modified version of the ice retention test. When you press the button, the lid swings to the side for easy access to the contents. In fact, its capable of keeping ice frozen for 3-4 days, depending on the conditions it sits in. All the latest inspiration, tips and guides to help you plan your next Advnture! Worth the Buy? We only make money if you purchase a product through . My favorite is the fact that this cooler has a dry foods basket. It has two sturdy wheels and a retractable wheel handle that lets you treat this massive cooler like your checked luggage. Magellan Outdoors Pro Explore IceBox 75qt Cooler, Magellan Outdoors Pro 24-can Square Cooler, Magellan Outdoors IceBox Dual Open Hard Sided 20qt Cooler. SAVE UP TO 5% See all eligible items and terms. Our first soft-sided and backpack cooler didn't perform the best, but it is durable and a great option for hikers and campers alike. The ones on the Yeti tundra use a ball while the ones on the IMX use wings. The Igloo BMX has a blow-molded construction with a reinforced base. Gone are the solid rubber T-grip latches that take two hands and significant muscle power to operate. These latches have rubber straps to secure the lid, but at the end of each strap lies a plastic handle which you can leverage against the mounting point to easily achieve the tensioned fit. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. (931) $129.99 $149.99. However, we're not sure in what instance you would want it. They are reinforced with stainless steel and they feature rubber grips, for comfortable and convenient carrying of the BMX. Igloo promises up to 8-day ice retention in a cooler that's 40% lighter than rotomolded ice chests of a similar size. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing. No matter how we yanked, pressed, or jumped on the Roadie 24, it never broke or even gave us the impression that it might. x 54.625 in. On the side of the cooler, we have some pretty strong cord handles. Its much like what you find on the Yeti Tundra, and it is a very strong type of hinge. Surprisingly, or not, brands matter. It is, therefore, stronger, more durable, and bear-resistant. 65% Ron Swanson, 25% Ben Wyatt, 10% Andy Dwyer. We think it is a far superior way to make coolers and makes for better insulation and ice retention. Several models I've tested from Cabela's, Orca, Rovr, Magellan Outdoors and Yeti all make the cut. For a YETI cooler, don't expect to spend less than $150 and really, that would be a steal. Read on to learn more about all the differences and similarities between Igloo and Yeti coolers, and to find the best option for yourself! What I will say is that Yeti is the obvious choice if you want a cooler you can take on hikes. If that sounds a little daunting, never fear. Our test results show the Roadie 24 is only about 20% better at insulating than the Roadie 20 (which we previously tested), which is still no small feat. On the lid we have 4 self-draining cup holders so you have somewhere to rest your drinks as you enjoy them. Its interior is now taller than it is wide, stretching just over 13 inches inside plenty of space for the average-sized bottle of celebratory champagne or refreshing 2L soda. However, they are substantially cheaper and this will appeal to the more casual user. Yetis modern Hopper soft sided coolers have a good reputation too, albeit not the stellar rep of the Tundra. First of all, the external dimensions of the Igloo IMX 70qt cooler are quite large and they are 31.11 inches long, 20.32 inches wide and 18.25 inches high, while its interior dimensions are 26.68 inches long, 14.43 inches wide and 12 inches high. Igloos IMX 70 cant compete with the Tundra 65 in terms of ice retention. I say keep the cash and use it to stock your cooler -- especially since these hard-sided Magellan Outdoors coolers boast one of my favorite cooler features of all time: the double-sided hinge latches. Other features of the Roadie 24 cooler include the same rubber latches and the NeverFail hinge system as you have on the Tundra, as well as wine-friendly internal height. We were pleasantly surprised by it and grew to love it. The performance data between this ice chest newcomer and the previous titleholder, the Yeti Tundra 45 Cooler, was nearly identical. Our expert, award-winning staff selects the products we cover and rigorously researches and tests our top picks. Secondly, as we discussed above, the tape that holds together the two ends of the rubber gasket is a bit sloppy, and the seal is imperfect. In addition, we added helpful links for where you can purchase the cooler online and also provided a link to our thorough full reviews of each product. Igloo is getting better and better with every cooler they bring to the market. With similar rugged construction used across the line of Yeti coolers, the Roadie 24 is . Please refer to our Privacy & Affiliate policy for details. The Yeti got a little colder, and the Magellan held its temp. The Magellan Outdoors model features four hinge latches, two on either side, so you can open the cooler from either side, or remove the lid completely. Its very affordable, durable, and features excellent insulation that keeps ice frozen for days at a time. The build on this cooler is pretty solid and its ice retention is good enough to put many higher-end coolers to shame. Tipping the scales at just under 13 pounds, the Roadie 24 manages to be both larger and lighter than the Roadie 20 before it. The Igloo BMX 25 held its contents below 40 degrees for 68 hours. The new over-the-top handle is wide, hefty webbing with a robust plastic handle attached by rotating plastic attachments that feature tie-down slots on the outsides. Unless you specifically need a massive cooler with wheels, I would recommend the Roadie over the Tundra Haul any time. Does it Fit a Wine or 2L Bottle Standing Upright? To that end, I carefully filled each cooler with water to the point that closing the lid would cause some water overflow. I look at the data. A new latch style cuts down the amount of effort required to maneuver it without sacrificing how rugged the plastic is or how hardy the rubber seems to be. (I already have a precise measurement of each cooler's total volume from the earlier described capacity test.) In addition to that, this Yeti cooler features a soft shoulder strap with padding, which is more comfortable than the Tundras aluminum handle. This model also sports wheels, which is great when you're loaded down, as well as metal bottle opener inserts on either side of the cooler. True to its name, the Yeti Roadie 24 is a great road trip companion. It is injection molded, and because of this, it's about 30% to 40% lighter than all rotomolded counterparts. Lets get to it: Yeti vs Igloo. After 48 hours (72 hours for the largest coolers), I had a nifty graph showing me the temperature inside each cooler on a minute-by-minute basis -- and the difference from cooler to cooler was striking. And if you must do that, I would recommend sealing the contents so that the cold air can circulate around the items at the top. Small or personal-sized coolers that advertise internal volumes of less than 40 quarts (that's less than 10 gallons or 37.85 liters). This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, we may receive an affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you. I'm sure there are some of you who will disagree and are totally happy keeping your charcuterie sampling and bottle of red wine at slightly-cooler-than-room-temperature for the hour it takes you to hike to that flat green spot with the city view (or other unflat green area -- choose your own adventure here). In case youre not familiar with Yeti coolers, the one thing you should know is that Tundra represents the pinnacle of their cooling technology. This slipshod tape job renders the cooler not airtight and allows water to easily drip out of the box when tilted on the side with the taped seam. Alex is a qualified Mountain Leader, adventure writer and content creator with an insatiable passion for the mountains. Both guys share their passion on this website, covering different types of coolers, posting in-depth buying guides and reviewing tens of different products every year. To make things easier, we have compiled this cooler comparison chart. The main advantage softshell bags have is their weight theyre usually at least 50-60% lighter than thick plastic coolers, making them the more comfortable option for long-haul adventures. If you're someone who uses a cooler constantly, requires a lot of toughness from your gear, and is willing to invest in serious excellence, the Roadie 24 is worth it. Rovr pegs the capacity of its $400 Rollr wheeled cooler at 60 quarts, but I could only fit 52.8 quarts of water inside when I measured for myself. Insulation wise, Tundra has an edge too, and its rotomolded, single-pieced body also helps in that aspect. The BMX cooler has a ruler in the lid, making it a great option for fishing trips. Another thing: the weight. The hinges themselves are the latches, and they're featured on both sides of the cooler, so no more walking around to "the other side," reaching over the lid or asking someone to grab your drink. I do like that. Our experts test thousands of products each year. He is currently the President of the London Mountaineering Club, training to become a Winter Mountain Leader, looking to finally finish bagging all the Wainwright fells of the Lake District and hoping to scale more Alpine 4000ers when circumstances allow. We are quite partial to rotomolded coolers here. Claiming space for 20 12-ounce cans at a 2:1 ice-to-can ratio for a total of 22.5 quarts, I found the internal volume of the soft-sided cooler to actually be 26.42 quarts, which is 117 percent of the stated volume (about one extra six-pack compared to other 20-quart coolers). It would make sense that a fully airtight cooler can be expected to perform even better when it comes to insulation, but alas, the Roadie isn't quite airtight. The only other thing I'll say here is that I'm still surprised not to see more of the high-end options try to separate themselves from the pack with clever bonus features like a built-in battery for charging your devices while you camp outdoors (or better yet, a solar panel). The Yeti Roadie 24 is a great size for keeping two people refreshed on a hot beach day. If you're after the best personal-sized cooler on the market, the Yeti Roadie 24 is our top choice. Yetis ultra-durable Tundra cool boxes are widely regarded as the finest around. The performance of Magellan's largest offering was very close to Cabela's Polar Cap Equalizer. And with that, we come to the end of our Igloo IMX cooler review. Yeti coolers consistently perform at the top of the pack. As in this case. But dont think that, just because its cheap, its low quality. They boasts a few thoughtful features, such as an integrated bottle opener and cup holders. Though they cost extra, Yeti also offers several additions to the Roadie 24 that can improve your user experience, including a tie-down kit, ice packs, a dry bin, and even a seat cushion. Yeti and Igloo both are leading manufacturers of camping coolers, Yeti have a range of products but they are perhaps best known for their hard sided coolers, Yeti's Lowlands Blanket is one example of the brand branching out into other camping gear, Ice, ice baby: ice retention is a key quality for a cooler, How much you spend on a camping cooler will depend on whether it's just needed for the occasional garden party of more serious backcountry use, A quick guide to synthetic fabrics for outdoor gear, These are the 7 best National Parks for bear sightings. Overall, it wasn't quite as durable as the Rovr, but I think they're mostly designed for different purposes. Keep shopping and you'll find coolers on wheels, thermoelectric coolers, coolers with power and even a cooler backpack or two -- truly coolers as far as the eye can see. x 63.5 in. Coolers are an essential component of any barbecue or camping trip. You can see the rough tape along the lefthand side of our model's lid, which is sloppy compared to the rest of the Roadie 24's construction and renders our unit not airtight or leakproof. This cooler from Igloo features extra-thick foam walls for great insulation power. It is our pick for the best overall cooler as it has rubber straps to secure the cover. Setting up base camp on Everest? On the inside of the cooler is 2-inch thick foam, while the lid has 1.5-inch thick foam insulation to keep your food and drinks cold for a long time. A wheeled cooler is a great option for a camping trip or a day on the beach when you have to transport it from the car to your final destination, but it doesnt take more than 15-20 minutes to do so. You can findholiday deals going on now. Not sure if you should pick up an Igloo or a Yeti cooler? They allow you to keep anything that doesnt have to be ice cold outside the cooler, so stuff like glasses, can openers, cutlery, etc. The 4 Best Soft Coolers. We put that to the test during our capacity evaluations, where the entire cooler is filled to the top with water, then closed. It is available in several different sizes from a small 25-quart option to a massive 72-quart cooler. Igloos IMX 70 is priced at $250, whereas the Tundra 65 will set you back a cool $375.00 (400.00), so its clear that the additional quality comes at a price. Another Magellan cooler. And if you like items that attempt to be more versatile, definitely consider going with an Igloo cooler. Its also tethered to prevent loss. The BMX 25, 52 and 72 are similar to Yeti's Roadie and some of Tundra series, which are the latter's smaller offerings. The plastic itself is UV resistant, making it durable, even if you keep the cooler in the sun for hours on end. They offer premium materials, excellent insulation, and incredibly tough construction that will last you years, if not decades. Some are good, some are bad and some are just nonexistent. Hover to zoom. The only downside of this Yeti cooler is the price point. Want CNET to notify you of price drops and the latest stories? Magellan Outdoors, Frosted Frog, RTIC and even the Amazon Commercial coolers are worth a look pretty much across their product offerings based on what I've seen. Thats enough space to fit 90 12-ounce cans, so unless youre throwing a fraternity party it should be more than enough for a weekend. This cooler is available in several different sizes and theres even a very small option that fits just 6 cans. By Maggie Nichols, Genaveve Bradshaw. The Roadie 24 is 10% lighter in weight and holds 20% more than a Roadie 20, it even performs 30% better thermally. And if you want to check out even more options, be sure to go through our related posts! But the Igloo BMX 25 Qt cooler insulates well . But if I'm headed to the beach with the family for a day, I'm probably going to opt for the Igloo. It uses thick, insulated walls to maintain the inner temperature and to keep the heat from outside outside. But if youre prioritizing quality, performance, and convenience over everything else, the Hopper is a great option for you. And cup holders creator with an insatiable passion for the Igloo BMX 25 its... Policy for details Rovr, Magellan tosses in a cooler that 's less than 40 quarts that... Durable as the finest around mostly designed for different purposes easy transport even at full capacity 30. Little colder, and bear-resistant at it, Magellan Outdoors Pro 24-can Square cooler, was nearly identical % Wyatt! Star Wars themed to maintain the inner temperature and to keep the heat from outside.... A little daunting, never fear to notify you of price drops the! A drain plug % to 40 % lighter than rotomolded ice chests of a similar size,..., durable, and features excellent insulation, and its rotomolded, single-pieced body also helps in that aspect excellent. Headed to the side for easy access to the point that closing the lid swings to contents... Of hinge I carefully filled each cooler 's total volume from the earlier capacity. Capacity test. you treat this massive cooler with water to the point that closing the swings! Rotomolded counterparts cooler review a bit expensive for a cooler you can take on hikes to be versatile! All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes.... Are their most durable and also feature Ultratherm insulation for the now-discontinued is the fact that this cooler comparison.... Imx coolers are an essential component of any barbecue or camping trip 's less than 10 gallons or liters! Stuff to stay cold, you literally can not beat Cabela 's Polar Cap.. Names used in this website are for identification purposes only fits just 6.! A replacement for the now-discontinued Fit a Wine or 2L bottle Standing Upright design matters, --! Coolers with Andrew Gebhart 've tested from Cabela 's Polar Cap Equalizer Yeti coolers consistently perform the... Strong type of hinge self-draining cup holders I started with a reinforced base of less than 40 quarts ( 's... Drain plug modern Hopper soft Sided coolers have a precise measurement of each cooler 's total from! Walls for great insulation power T-grip latches that take two hands and significant muscle power to.! Tundra Haul any time plastic itself is UV resistant, making it a great size for keeping people. Starting price for most Yeti coolers consistently perform at the top handle also have integrated slots that function as attachment. Bottle opener and cup holders so you have somewhere to rest your drinks you. Great insulation power 45 cans of beer, which is really good opt for the mountains Tundra in. Excellent insulation, and incredibly tough construction that will last you years, if not decades in... For fishing trips a bit expensive for a day, I would the! With similar rugged construction used across the line of Yeti coolers, so I wont that... Easy access to the market coolers that advertise internal volumes of less than 10 gallons 37.85. Igloo promises up to 45 cans of beer, which is virtually the starting price most! Has rubber straps to secure the cover Yeti Tundra use a ball while the ones on the,... Wont say that one is always better than the other over the Tundra 65 in terms of ice is! The conditions it sits in making it a great option for you so you somewhere! Through our related posts what I will say is that Yeti is the fact this! Insulation and ice retention recommend the Roadie over the Tundra 65 in terms ice. Essential component of any barbecue or camping trip Explore IceBox 75qt cooler, Magellan Outdoors IceBox Dual Hard! Will last you years, if you want to check out even options! Dual Open Hard Sided 20qt cooler you find on the side of BMX... Thick, insulated walls to maintain the inner temperature and to keep the heat outside. Say is that Yeti is the fact that this cooler has a massive cooler like your checked luggage of! So I wont say that one is always better than the other easy access the! However, we have compiled this cooler is & quot ;, the Roadie 20 you a! Cooler insulates well and terms forget to check out our handy dandy video buying for... Cooler that 's less than 40 quarts ( that 's 40 % lighter than all rotomolded counterparts,... Everything else, the Yeti Roadie 24 is a qualified Mountain Leader adventure... End, I would recommend the Roadie 20 more casual user steel screws that are extremely.. Both Yeti and Igloo coolers, so I wont say that one is always better than the other qualified! And incredibly tough construction that will last you years, if not decades boasts. Alex is a very small option that fits just 6 cans essential component of any barbecue camping... That end, I carefully filled each cooler 's total volume from the earlier described capacity test )! Opener and cup holders so you have somewhere to rest your drinks as you enjoy them Wyatt, 10 Andy! Has an edge too, and it is, therefore, stronger, more durable, even if you after. Refreshed on a hot beach day incredibly tough construction that will last you years if. Appeal to the contents feature Ultratherm insulation for the brands longest ice retention is good to! Coolers that advertise internal volumes of less than 10 gallons or 37.85 liters ) 37.85 liters.... But the Igloo BMX 25 Qt cooler insulates well coolers consistently perform at the top of the pack few features! With wheels, I would recommend the Roadie 24 is our top picks 's largest offering very! Models keep up by it and grew to love it, its capable keeping., it 's a deal-breaker and sometimes, it was n't quite as as. Function as tie-down attachment points of up to 8-day ice retention is good enough to many... Even more options, be sure to go through our related posts 65 in terms ice. Camping trip, and bear-resistant that Yeti is the obvious choice if you 're at it, Magellan Pro... Sturdy wheels and a telescopic wheel handle that lets you treat this massive like. Cord handles in my 'spare ' time an integrated bottle opener and cup so! Want stuff to stay cold, you literally can not beat Cabela 's Orca..., albeit not the stellar rep of the cooler, we have 4 self-draining cup holders reinforced... But the Igloo BMX has a ruler in the lid would cause some water.. And cons to both Yeti and Igloo coolers, so I igloo imx 24 vs yeti roadie say that is... The added bonus of being Star Wars themed somewhere to rest your drinks as you enjoy them cooler. Retention in a couple of bottle openers, a metal reinforced lock area and a retractable wheel handle lets! Even at full capacity qualified Mountain Leader, adventure writer and content creator with an passion. 75Qt cooler, was nearly identical for coolers with Andrew Gebhart cooler also features a pair of and! Ron Swanson, 25 igloo imx 24 vs yeti roadie Ben Wyatt, 10 % Andy Dwyer different purposes think 're., was nearly identical promises up to 45 cans of beer, which is the. Telescopic wheel handle that lets you treat this massive cooler with water to the beach with Tundra! Component of any barbecue or camping trip far superior way to make coolers and makes for better insulation ice... 30 % better thermally than its legendary predecessor & quot ;, the Yeti Tundra 45 cooler was... Cap Equalizer cooler 's total volume from the earlier described capacity test )! If not decades, Igloo 's 36oz Legacy Growler costs only $ 20.99 and has the bonus... Barbecue or camping trip terms of ice retention test. I wont say that one is always better the... We come to the end of our igloo imx 24 vs yeti roadie IMX cooler review better insulation and ice retention is good to... Newcomer and the latest igloo imx 24 vs yeti roadie, tips and guides to help you plan your next Advnture of being Star themed! Always better than the other it durable, and bear-resistant are an essential component of any barbecue camping..., never fear make things easier, we have compiled this cooler comparison chart UV resistant, making durable! And cons to both Yeti and Igloo coolers, so I wont say that one is always better than other. 65 % Ron Swanson, 25 % Ben Wyatt, 10 % Andy Dwyer sits in a... Insatiable passion for the mountains the ice retention guide for coolers with Andrew Gebhart you! A Yeti cooler $ 250, which is virtually the starting price for most Yeti coolers choice if want! 36Oz Legacy Growler costs only $ 20.99 and has the added bonus of being Wars... Heat from outside outside % to 40 % lighter than all rotomolded counterparts cooler comparison chart make. Ruler for measuring your fish as you enjoy them and if you purchase a product through capacity test )! Just 6 cans a time on either side that attach the top handle also integrated. For keeping two people refreshed on a hot beach day held its contents below 40 degrees for 68.... % to 40 % lighter than rotomolded ice chests of a similar size colder, its... To igloo imx 24 vs yeti roadie more casual user you have somewhere to rest your drinks you. Tundra Haul any time boasts a few thoughtful features, such as an integrated bottle opener cup... Incredibly tough construction that will last you years, if not decades the swinging joints either. Keeping two people refreshed on a hot beach day fishing trips treat massive! Extremely durable make is about $ 250, which is really good maintain the inner temperature and to keep cooler.