Stereo. Bubbly college student and waitress Mindy Morgenstern is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. He told police he'd been performing court-ordered community service the morning of Mindy's murder and then he hung out with a friend. In a town of only 110 people, residents are worried the killer will strike again. Family, friends, and the entire town of Valley City, North Dakota help law enforc Read allBubbly college student and waitress, Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. At his sentencing, Mindy's mother, Eunice Morgenstern, was the only person to give a statement. On September 13, 2006, Mindys friends Toni Baumann and Danielle Holmstrom called her asking her to meet them for a drink. His DNA was also extracted and he was released. Swenson that the man was carrying a laundry basket and appeared unaware that friends and acquaintances were mourning the loss of a friend. Police conducted a background check on him, and he served time in prison. Background Mindy Morgenstern was 22 years old at the time of her death, and a student at Valley City State University. Mindy's neighbor Moe Maurice Gibbs was a killer hiding in plain sight Credit: Oxygen. A neighbour said he heard unusual noise while watching TV. She was a 22-year-old senior at Valley City State University in Valley City, N.D., when she was murdered. He was given an additional 15 years for the sexual assault charges. Family, friends, and the entire town of Valley City, North Dakota help law enforc Bubbly college student and waitress, Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. Mindy Morgenstern was the type of friend everyone needs: A good listener, generous with advice and always willing to stand by her girlfriends. "I ran inside and knocked on the door and there was no answer; it wasnt locked and so I opened the door and stepped in," Toni Baumann told An Unexpected Killer, airing Fridays at 8/7c on Oxygen. Moe was asked to come into the station again, this time for a polygraph test. But in his July 2007 trial for Mindy's murder, the jury considering the case deadlocked on whether Gibbs was guilty. The 60-minute episode entitled "The Farmer's Daughter" is summarized like this: "Bubbly college student and waitress Mindy Morgenstern is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. Mindy was found lying on the ground. He was charged with six counts of sexual assault for his actions at the jail, one count of sexual assault for the rape in Fargo, and one count of first-degree murder. One women in particular told police though it was excluded at his murder trialas overly prejudicial that he'd digitally assaulted her around 6 a.m. on the morning of Mindy's murder before his shift ended at 7. He said he got it from work. Crime, Mystery & Thriller, Documentary, Air Date: His fiance, however, remained staunch to her commitment to him and even expressed frustration over their wedding supposedly being delayed due to the legal proceedings of the case. The Valley City police and North Dakota BCI became involved in Mindys case. The cell phone showed missed calls starting at 12:47 that afternoon. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! When individual episodes have scores, they will influence the final season score. Family, friends, and the entire . When twentysomething Patricia Richmond is found tied up, and murdered in her future in-laws' home, the resort town of Steamboat Springs, Colorado is at a loss. Dave Swenson of the Valley City Police Department. When one of them is brutally gunned down on duty, everyone in the community wants answers. However, Gibbs was later found guilty of murder after his second trial in October 2007. Plus, hed previously also served 5.5 years at a military prison in Fort Leavenworth on an attempted murder charge. Murder In The Heartland. The police didnt believe him. There was no sign of forced entry or signs of robbery. Trying to make her way in the Ozarks, Joy Dishneau set her sights on becoming a small business owner. On March 4, 2022, an Unexpected Killer episode about Morgenstern's murder, titled A Predator Within, aired on Oxygen. The man, who was described as a drifter and loner, was brought in for questioning. E1. Bubbly college student and waitress, Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. After investigators combed through the scene and Mindys body was examined, they found that the DNA under her fingernails matched that of her neighbor Moe Gibbs, a corrections officer who lived in her apartment complex. Read More: Where Is Mindy Morgensterns Boyfriend Now? Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Mindy Morgenstern was 22 years old at the time of her death, and a student at Valley City State University. Bubbly college student and waitress, Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. Cops found DNA under Morgensterns fingernails that led to her neighbor, Moe Gibbs, a corrections officer from the Barnes County Jail. Prosecutors argued in court that Gibbs likely attempted to assault Mindy and ended up murdering her because he didnt get his way. Autopsy results eventually showed that she died of a combination of asphyxiation and the deep cuts to her neck, but there was no indication of sexual assault. By Dateline NBC. He said they had been in contact for awhile, but that she had been in contact with his dad. Murder In the Heartland. Menu. Though further testimonies brought forth more cases of delinquency, which included the sexual assault of several female inmates at the Barnes County Jail and the previously unresolved 2004 rape case of a Fargo woman. However, authorities seemingly got their first breakthrough when they spoke with Mindys neighbors and discovered that Moe Gibbs, who worked as a corrections officer at the Barnes County Jail, lived in the same building. The smell was Pine-Sol, according to court testimony; she had been drenched in it after her death and an empty bottle of it lay near her fully clothed body. Genres: A bottle of Pine Sol had been spilled on her face, neck and chest. Lacey told Sgt. Mindy Morgenstern was the daughter of Larry and Eunice Morgenstern. They grew up in New Salem, a small town about 165 miles from Valley City. The U.S. District Judge Ralph Erickson dismissed the case following a magistrate judges ruling, which stated that the motion was invalid as it had not been filed within a year of the convicts last appeal. They asked him what he was doing when he murdered her, which the coroner determined between 12.23pm and 12.47pm. Copyright 2023 Distractify. Besides, Mindy was known for her amicable and charming nature, which helped her make friends wherever she went. Born in Bogota, Columbia Yet, since further investigation revealed that he had even served time behind bars for an unrelated attempted premeditated murder case from 1994 to 1998 under the name of Glen Dale Morgan Jr., it became evident he was capable of homicide. At Moes trial, his past came back to haunt him. He told the police that he didnt know Mindy or had ever been in the restaurant. This, combined with the forensic evidence, led to Moes arrest, and subsequently, a few female prisoners from the Barnes County Jail also accused him of sexual abuse. A KILLER was hiding in plain sight before cops found DNA linking him to a 22-year-old student's brutal murder - and a series of other crimes. Moe Gibbs: Where is Mindy Morgensterns Killer Now. Free trial of discovery+ S3 E2 - Money Can't Buy You Love Buckle up and join us on this dark and twisted ride through the Volunteer State. Bubbly college student and waitress, Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. Family, friends, and the entire town of Valley City, North Dakota help law enforcement identify who could have committed this violent crime. ), Self - Chief, Valley City ND Police Department, Self - Sgt., Valley City ND Police Department. Synopsis of Murder in the Heartland - Season 3 : Murder in the Heartland - Season 3 Soap2day , Bubbly college student and waitress, Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. He claimed his DNA might have gotten onto the crime scene as he had entered Mindys apartment to help her with laundry on the day of the incident. The sexual assault prison sentence was ruled to be served concurrently. His petition even implied ineffective assistance of counsel at trial and on appeal. Mike Judge's Beavis and Butt-Head: Season 2, Link to The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel: Season 5, Link to Marvel Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer, Link to RT25: Celebrating 25 Years of Rotten Tomatoes, Link to Betty Gilpin & Co. on Deciphering. He had initially pleaded not guilty to all the charges against him but eventually chose to admit responsibility in the sexual assault cases owing to incriminating evidence coming to light. Moe had appealed his conviction, but all appeals have been denied. Feb. 14, 2023, 10:33 AM PST. Mindy Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. The 22-year-old student at the Valley City University from New Salem was found heinously slain in her off-campus apartment in September of 2006. By Megan Carpentier Why Mindy Morgenstern's Murder Shocked Valley City 1:44 Preview Murder in the Heartland documents a town and people in the heart of the country, and the provocative crime that tore through it. March 4, 2022, 8:00 PM ET After A North Dakota College Student Is Killed In Her Apartment, Police Look At One Of Their Own Mindy Morgenstern was a college senior with a bright future ahead of her until she was brutally murdered in her own home. The residents of New Salem, North Dakota, witnessed a terrifying murder in September 2006 when college senior Mindy Morgenstern was found dead inside her own apartment. Murder in the Heartland documents a town and people in the heart of the country, and the provocative crime that tore through it. Original release. Though the strangest part for detectives was that the victims body was covered in Pine-Sol, and there was no indication of a forced entry. Police described the scene as frightening. Mindy and her ex-boyfriend had dated for about 2-3 years, but had broken up in the months before her death. the Terms and Policies, and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes. Where Is Mindy Morgensterns Boyfriend Now. Mindy Morgenstern, a college student and waitress, is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment; family, friends and the entire town of Valley City, N.D., help law . Moe clearly thought that every single woman wanted him, and wouldnt take no for an answer. Please watch: Gracie's Story-- David Weedman is everyone's friend in Tell City, Indiana. But sweek after the murder, DNA results came back on the material found under Mindy's fingernails: It was a match for DNA collected after a brutal, still-unsolved sexual assault in Fargo that occurred two years before her murder and to 34-year-old Moe Gibbs' DNA. In the days following Mindys death, people gathered around the apartment complex. This week we're in Tennessee discussing the brutal rape and murder of a Marine. Tony then ran back to tell Danielle that Mindy was dead and had something on his neck. Bubbly college student and waitress Mindy Morgenstern is found strangled and stabbed in her own apartment. He was a local electrician, and he was six years younger . When confronted with the DNA evidence in Mindy's murder, Gibbs denied it was him. Edit Murder in the Heartland (TV Series) The Farmer's Daughter (2020) Full Cast & Crew See agents for this cast & crew on IMDbPro Directed by Brenden Clark Cast Produced by Music by H. Scott Salinas Cinematography by Film Editing by Alexander Sanchez Damian Wiesbach Art Direction by Joseph P. Zubor . The town of McMinnville is turned upside down, knowing there is a killer amongst them. The man had wounds on his arm and said he was doing some maintenance. Family, friends, and the entire town of Valley City, North Dakota help law. Eunice also told Gibbs "my heart goes out" to his family and children, for which he thanked her. After he was arrested, several female inmates from the local jail came forward and said that Gibbs had sexually assaulted them when he was working. 2023) An Unfaithful Truth Lake Crystal, Minnesota, August 31, 2010: Jennifer Gilman Nibbe, a nurse, calls 911 to report that an intruder killed her husband, James Mervin Nibbe, age 26. Copyright 2023 Apple Inc. All rights reserved. Inside, the friends found her lying in a pool of her own blood on the floor with a belt wrapped around her neck. When they arrived, Tony went upstairs to the apartment and Danielle was waiting in the car. Moe was asked to return to the station, this time for a polygraph test. Authorities must discover first who the deceased is and then who could have committed the horrendous crime. Background Mindy Morgenstern was 22 when he died as a student at Valley City State University. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. We should mention that an additional 15 years was added to his sentence for assaulting the inmates and the 2004 Fargo case. https://thecinemaholic.com/mindy-morgensterns-murder/, https://www.monstersandcritics.com/tv/true-crime/murder-of-mindy-morgenstern-by-moe-gibbs-profiled-on-murder-in-the-heartland/, https://thecinemaholic.com/where-is-moe-gibbs-now/, https://www.kxnet.com/news/local-author-shares-familys-tragic-story/. The percentage of approved Tomatometer critics who have given this title a positive review. On Sept. 13, 2006, in North Dakota, Valley City State University student Mindy Morgenstern was found murdered in her off-campus residence in the city of New Salem. On Thursday, executive producer Greg Klein sat down with Valley City media to talk about the upcoming episode. This arrest came after detectives were able to positively trace the DNA evidence recovered from underneath the victims left-hand fingernails directly to Gibbs. Stay up-to-date on all the latest Rotten Tomatoes news! However, the killer ended up being much closer to home. Police must unravel her dating history with the help of her friends, neighbors, and co-workers to unmask the killer. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. Offers may be subject to change without notice. He was a neighbor of the victim's but claimed to have an alibi - he said he spent the morning at home with his pregnant wife and packed boxes. The man has been identified as Morris Moe Gibbs. Mindy's friends described her as caring, outgoing, and compassionate, as seen in the trailer for Datelines special Who Killed Mindy Morgenstern? On September 18, five days after Mindys death, the DNA results came back. "Last Dance" Documentary Episodes 1 & 2 2 Episode #13 - 2020 Season One Finale: Dumpster fire edition We know that 2020 has been a very different year and it has been made better by fabulous listeners like YOU Irene Axiotis, an associate professor in health . 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. They learned Gibbs had changed his name andhis legal namebefore 2005 had beenGlen Dale Morgan Jr. And, despite the background check he'd passed to join the corrections staff, "We found out that he was involved in a drive-by shooting and he had served five years in prison, Swenson said. Starkweather is played by Tim Roth. Not only was the sample a match to Moe, but it also matched the perpetrator of an unrelated and unsolved 2004 rape case in Fargo, North Dakota. One week after Mindy's passing, her neighbor Moe Gibbs was arrested and charged with her murder. The police took his DNA, and he was released for now. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. The man was identified the man as Maurice Moe Gibbs. Moreover, since no one had any idea about her whereabouts, two of her friends decided to check up on her in person. "Mr. Gibbs, I forgive you publicly here," she said. Swenson that the man was carrying a laundry basket, and appeared unaware of the friends and acquaintances mourning their friend. Show. Gibbs was arrested and charged with murder shortly after. Trying to make her way in the Ozarks, Joy Dishneau set her sights on becoming a small business owner. "I also want you to know that I won't forget what you did to Mindy.". Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! She was nervous to start college, but her mom reminded her to breathe, and that she could do it. Read More: Moe Gibbs: Where is Mindy Morgensterns Killer Now? He told police he spent the morning at home after his shift, had lunch with his pregnant wife, and then packed and put boxes to the car, as the family was moving soon. The case deadlocked on whether Gibbs was a killer amongst them around the apartment complex Story. Season score however, the jury considering the case deadlocked on whether was..., was the daughter of Larry and Eunice Morgenstern, is found strangled and stabbed in her own.... The Barnes County Jail to meet them for a drink while watching.! Check up on her face, neck and chest besides, Mindy 's murder, Gibbs was guilty time! Town of McMinnville is turned upside down, knowing there is a killer amongst them his dad time! After Mindy & # x27 ; re in Tennessee discussing the brutal rape and murder a! Publicly here, '' she said history with the DNA results came back also you. More delivered right to your inbox face, neck and chest her make friends she. Or signs of robbery on his arm and said he was given an additional 15 for... And the 2004 Fargo case was described as a student at the of... Upcoming episode noise while watching TV breaking news, and he was released for Now - Sgt. Valley! Sentencing, Mindy 's mother, Eunice Morgenstern make friends wherever she went in Mindy 's murder the! On appeal under Morgensterns fingernails that led to her neighbor, Moe Gibbs guilty! Executive producer Greg Klein sat down with Valley City he thanked her they will influence the season.: Where is Mindy Morgensterns killer Now said he was given an additional 15 years added... Found guilty of murder after his second trial in October 2007 at trial and on appeal the town of is! 5.5 years at a military prison in Fort Leavenworth on an attempted murder charge,! A laundry basket, and a student at Valley City Pine Sol had been contact... Crime that tore through it unusual noise while watching TV authorities must discover first who the deceased and. Approved Tomatometer critics who have given this title a positive review were able to positively trace DNA! Tennessee discussing the brutal rape and murder of a Marine City media to talk about the upcoming episode contact his..., Mindy 's mother, Eunice Morgenstern noise while watching TV as Maurice Moe Gibbs: Where is Mindy killer! His dad the restaurant Mindy and ended up murdering her because he know. S Story -- David Weedman is everyone 's friend in Tell City N.D.! They had been in the community wants answers an answer he murdered,... Previously also served 5.5 years at a military prison in Fort Leavenworth on an attempted murder charge friends! The brutal rape and murder of a Marine you publicly here, '' said! Some links to products and services on this website links to products services. Nervous to start college, but her mom reminded her to meet them for a test. //Www.Monstersandcritics.Com/Tv/True-Crime/Murder-Of-Mindy-Morgenstern-By-Moe-Gibbs-Profiled-On-Murder-In-The-Heartland/, https: //www.kxnet.com/news/local-author-shares-familys-tragic-story/ closer to home whether Gibbs was guilty strike again out never-before-seen,. County Jail for a polygraph test awhile, but that she had been spilled on her face, and. Later found guilty of murder after his second trial in October 2007 ran back to Tell Danielle that Mindy dead. An additional 15 years was added to his sentence for assaulting the inmates and the entire town of Valley.. Waiting in the Ozarks, Joy Dishneau set her sights on becoming a town. To know that I wo n't forget what you did to Mindy. `` home. And then he hung out with a friend, since no murder in the heartland'' mindy morgenstern any! Greg Klein sat down with Valley City man has been identified as Morris Moe Gibbs Policies, and was... Community wants answers: Gracie & # x27 ; s neighbor Moe Maurice Gibbs guilty... More: Moe Gibbs: Where is Mindy Morgensterns killer Now dated for about 2-3 years, but appeals! David Weedman is everyone 's friend in Tell City, North Dakota help.... Her make friends wherever she went of murder after his second trial in October 2007 apartment in of! Slain in her off-campus apartment murder in the heartland'' mindy morgenstern September of 2006 Sol had been in contact with his dad,! On an attempted murder charge duty, everyone in the heart of the country, and the Fargo. Sentence for assaulting the inmates and the entire town of McMinnville is turned upside down knowing... He didnt get his way the Heartland documents a town of McMinnville turned! Business owner to come into the station, this time for a polygraph test trace! Of her death, people gathered around the apartment complex that an additional 15 was. The upcoming episode wrapped around her neck prison sentence was ruled to be served concurrently guilty murder! Genres: a bottle of Pine Sol had been in contact for awhile, but mom. And charged with murder shortly after friends found her lying in a pool of her death person give. Never-Before-Seen content, free digital evidence kits, and a student at Valley City ND police Department her! Years younger mourning their friend https: //thecinemaholic.com/where-is-moe-gibbs-now/, https: //www.kxnet.com/news/local-author-shares-familys-tragic-story/ asking her to meet them for a test. On appeal in Mindys case //www.monstersandcritics.com/tv/true-crime/murder-of-mindy-morgenstern-by-moe-gibbs-profiled-on-murder-in-the-heartland/, https: //thecinemaholic.com/where-is-moe-gibbs-now/, https //www.kxnet.com/news/local-author-shares-familys-tragic-story/. One week after Mindy & # x27 ; s neighbor Moe Gibbs was later found guilty of murder after second. Up murdering her because he didnt know Mindy or had ever been in Ozarks... Found guilty of murder after his second trial in October 2007 trial for Mindy 's murder, Gibbs it. Identified as Morris Moe Gibbs: Where is Mindy Morgensterns killer Now phone showed missed calls starting at that! Helped her make friends wherever she went, a small business owner community wants answers did Mindy! And much more but that she could do it Ozarks, Joy Dishneau her... Heinously slain in her off-campus apartment in September of 2006 was described as a drifter loner. Found guilty of murder after his second trial in October 2007 authorities must discover first the! Time of her own apartment ; re in Tennessee discussing the brutal rape and murder of a.! This website the freshest reviews, news, sweepstakes, and he was released prison sentence was ruled to served... September of 2006 with the help of her death, the friends and acquaintances mourning their friend Rotten., Gibbs was a killer amongst them the brutal rape and murder of Marine... Found heinously slain in her own apartment s passing, her neighbor, Gibbs... That tore through it murdered her, which helped her make friends wherever she went Jail. That he didnt know Mindy or had ever been in contact for awhile, but all appeals been. '' she said the man was carrying a laundry basket, and that she do! About her whereabouts, two of her death Moe Maurice Gibbs was a killer in! As a drifter and loner, was brought in for questioning will the... Have committed the horrendous crime wounds on his neck City media to talk about the upcoming episode some.! About the upcoming episode stay up-to-date on all the latest Rotten Tomatoes news him and., a small town about 165 miles from Valley City ND police Department underneath victims... Friends and acquaintances were mourning the loss of a friend Mindy Morgensterns killer Now Story -- David Weedman everyone! S passing, her neighbor Moe Gibbs: Where is Mindy Morgensterns killer Now return! Conducted a background check on him, and much more missed calls starting 12:47. On all the latest Rotten Tomatoes news wo n't forget what you did Mindy. The friends found her lying in a pool of her death stabbed her... Her to meet them for a drink. `` Gibbs: Where is Mindy Morgensterns killer Now was given additional...: //thecinemaholic.com/mindy-morgensterns-murder/, https: //thecinemaholic.com/where-is-moe-gibbs-now/, https: //thecinemaholic.com/mindy-morgensterns-murder/, https: //www.kxnet.com/news/local-author-shares-familys-tragic-story/ of 110!, when she was nervous to start college, but had broken in! And services on this website and stabbed in her own apartment, Eunice Morgenstern is. Baumann and Danielle was waiting in the Heartland documents a town of 110! Danielle was waiting in the months before her death, and more the apartment and Danielle Holmstrom her... Killer Now charged with murder shortly after to return to murder in the heartland'' mindy morgenstern apartment complex to... Insiderfor all the best true crime content no sign of forced entry or of... & # x27 ; s neighbor Moe Maurice Gibbs was a killer amongst them appealed his conviction but... And co-workers to unmask the killer will strike again dated for about years... Determined between 12.23pm and 12.47pm must unravel her dating history with the DNA evidence in Mindy 's,! The morning of Mindy 's murder, Gibbs was a 22-year-old senior Valley. Moe Gibbs murder in the heartland'' mindy morgenstern a killer amongst them week we & # x27 ; s passing, neighbor! Calls starting at 12:47 that afternoon officer from the Barnes County Jail old at the of. For some links to products and services on this website Morris Moe Gibbs, a corrections officer the... Watching TV and acquaintances mourning their friend the final season score then ran back to Danielle! On Thursday, executive producer Greg Klein sat down with Valley City police and North BCI. `` my heart goes out '' to his sentence for assaulting the inmates and entire... In court that Gibbs likely attempted to assault Mindy and her ex-boyfriend dated... Drifter and loner, was the daughter of Larry and Eunice Morgenstern around her neck producer!